Hi all
My wife and I are new to the caravanning scene and are just after a bit of advice on tow vehicles .
Having 2 kids , were after a 7 seat vehicle that we can use for towing a triple bunk caravan .
We havent purchased a van yet , however most vans weve looked at are around 1300-1600kg Tare weight and about 17-19 ft, so nothing too big and not the off-road style . And yes , we need a car first as we only have 1 at the moment and the caravan most likely wont be purchased for another 4 months or so .
Preferably my wife would prefer a Petrol car as she doesnt like diesels , plus the car would be used for a lot of short school runs rather than long, across Australia journeys.
Hence the thought of looking at Kluger AWD as an option......seen a few from 2013 and a couple from 2014 in AWD that are the same price as a 2006 Prado thats done 200,000 + km .
Has anyone on here ever used or are currently using a Kluger to tow a van and what are your thoughts??
Any input or advice would be very much appreciated as we are new to the scene and arent quite sure where to look or where to start .
Many thanks
Hayden
littledick said
12:19 PM May 4, 2021
I had a 2009 Kluger and towed pretty good but only limited at the time to 2.0T. I also had a fold up drawer bar that took the ball load to 270Kl.
Traded it for a Ford Territory. Towed 2.7T. Didn't have the van or car for long, traded for a Pajero. 6 vans in 10 yrs, now have the Ford Wildtrak.
The Kluger was a good car overall, but watch your van weight. Not sure what the new one capacity is.
Dick.
Hayden said
12:22 PM May 4, 2021
Hi Dick
Thank you for your reply .
Pretty sure the newer Klugers have 2t braked capacity and 200kg tow ball weight ....Weve also looked at the V6 Petrol Pajero , but again for the same money as a Kluger , the Pajero would be a 2007/2008 model
Whenarewethere said
12:53 PM May 4, 2021
I don't tow, but have a Landrover Freelander which has the Ford 2.0L Ecoboost petrol engine. It does 2 tonnes. But like all cars you need to which your car's payload. It is frighteningly quickly how payload vanishes.
yobarr said
01:54 PM May 4, 2021
Hayden wrote:
Hi all My wife and I are new to the caravanning scene and are just after a bit of advice on tow vehicles . Having 2 kids , were after a 7 seat vehicle that we can use for towing a triple bunk caravan . We havent purchased a van yet , however most vans weve looked at are around 1300-1600kg Tare weight and about 17-19 ft, so nothing too big and not the off-road style . And yes , we need a car first as we only have 1 at the moment and the caravan most likely wont be purchased for another 4 months or so . Preferably my wife would prefer a Petrol car as she doesnt like diesels , plus the car would be used for a lot of short school runs rather than long, across Australia journeys. Hence the thought of looking at Kluger AWD as an option......seen a few from 2013 and a couple from 2014 in AWD that are the same price as a 2006 Prado thats done 200,000 + km . Has anyone on here ever used or are currently using a Kluger to tow a van and what are your thoughts?? Any input or advice would be very much appreciated as we are new to the scene and arent quite sure where to look or where to start . Many thanks Hayden
Hi Hayden it pains me to say so,but the Pajero is a much more capable tow vehicle than is the Kluger.On paper,the Kluger has carrying capacity of 750kg before you reach GVM,or maximum allowed weight on wheels of car,of 2720kg.With your maximum allowed towball weight,which is indeed 200kg,you will instantly add around 300kg to your car's rear axle,having removed 100kg from the front axle.This means you have maximum carrying capacity of 450kg left for ALL your gear,family,tools etc. Unfortunately,I do not recall the carrying capacity of the car's rear axle,but that is something to be very wary of.When I get home,I will look in my records to see if I can find that for you.Maximum allowed total weight of car and van (GCM) is 4720kg,but you will never be able to get near that because towball weight becomes part of the car's weight when the van is attached.The best you're ever likely to achieve is around 4500kg,with absolutely perfect loading of the car.The Pajero,on the other hand,has payload of around 780kg but a much higher GCM of 5530kg,so towing a 2000kg van could be done easily,with its 5520kg GCM (maximum total weight on wheels of car and van).Pajero tow capacity is 2500kg,so you might be able to get weight out of the car,and into the van? Whilst I am absolutely NO fan of Pajeros,they have proven to be good,reliable vehicles for many thousands of families,over many years. The Kluger too is a grear car,but I think that it would struggle to do what you want.Weights are a minefield for "newbies",and are misunderstood by many of the more experienced vanners,so please feel free to ask questions.Remember,the only silly question is the one that wasn't asked! Cheers
Thanks yobarr
Yes the weight scenario has certainly been an eye opener for us and a bit of a struggle to get our heads around .
So just to clarify, you think that a rare weight van of around 1300kg would be pushing it in regards to the capability of a Kluger ?? FYI we have two kids under 5 , so theres a bit of stuff to pack , plus I imagine well have the usual Weber q , bikes , Portable fridge/freezer and camping chairs etc .
Again , appreciate your help
Hayden said
05:54 PM May 4, 2021
Thanks yobarr
Yes the weight scenario has certainly been an eye opener for us and a bit of a struggle to get our heads around .
So just to clarify, you think that a rare weight van of around 1300kg would be pushing it in regards to the capability of a Kluger ?? FYI we have two kids under 5 , so theres a bit of stuff to pack , plus I imagine well have the usual Weber q , bikes , Portable fridge/freezer and camping chairs etc .
Again , appreciate your help
Whenarewethere said
06:10 PM May 4, 2021
Hayden wrote:
we have two kids under 5 , so theres a bit of stuff to pack, plus I imagine well have the usual Weber q, bikes, Portable fridge/freezer and camping chairs etc.
We don't have kids!
Example of payload in our car:
Be very careful of what you add. It adds up extremely quickly and you have no capacity for critical items!
We don't have a tow bar which weigh a far bit themselves, bull bar, draw system, tool box, aerials, driving lights, winch, under body protection, roof platform (did have one, got rid of it to save weight), boat, outboard, or kayak, life vests, fishing equipment, UHF radio (looking at getting one), BBQ & cleaning equipment (boil only & buy fried food when in town). We only have a tiny fridge and small battery. Our wheels are small at 255/60 R18 30kg each.
Items added to our car:
145.000 People (one has to reduce a bit!) x2
12.000 Roof rack rails & 1 pair cross bars x1 _3.600 Second pair cross bars x1 _4.000 Solar panel & tyre bracket x1 30.000 Wheel second spare x1 _4.600 Fuel rack aluminium x1 36.000 Fuel tanks 10 litres x4 _3.000 Fuel rack aluminium small x1 _9.000 Fuel tanks 5 litres x2 _0.080 Fuel tank nozzle x2 15.200 Solar panels x1 12.000 Sand tracks x4 12.000 Awning x1
20.972 Water container 10 litre 0.486 x2 42.656 Water container 5 litre 0.332 x8 _3.414 Water container 1 litre 0.138 x3 _1.000 Thermos flask x1
_3.700 Fire extinguishers 1kg x2 _0.300 Hi vis vests x2 16.000 Compressor 4.5kg x3 _1.350 Air tank 4 litres x1 _0.636 Air dryer x1 _0.388 Pressure gauge x1 _0.084 Pressure gauge electronic x2 _0.132 Fitting x1 _0.556 Air hose 6 metre ARB orange x1 _0.426 Air hose 2 metre blue x1 _0.362 Air hose 1.5 metre blue x1 _0.264 Air hose 0.8 metre blue x1 _0.106 Air duster cleaner x1
_2.100 Jumper leads 175 anderson to clamp x1 _3.900 Jumper leads 300 amp continuous x1 29.000 Battery 26ah 8.35kg + brackets x3 _1.000 MPPT x1 _1.490 6awg 4m 50ah anderson x1 _0.954 8awg 4m 50ah anderson x1 _0.254 12awg 2.2m anderson x1 _0.342 12awg 2m 50/35 ah anderson x1 _0.282 12awg 35ah fridge lead 1 _0.112 Fridge power lead x1 _0.210 Fridge 240 volt lead x1 15.000 Fridge 28 litres inc. extra insulation x1 _0.100 12 volt lead 1m x3 _0.700 White towel to cover fridge x1
0.216 Window sun shade front x1 0.366 Window sun shade rest of windows x1 6.500 Mosquito enclosure x1 1.000 Ground sheet heavy x1 0.626 Ground sheet tent cover light x1 1.088 Tent poles telescopic 0.544 x2 1.900 Tent poles and pegs x2 1.600 Tent ropes & pegs (10 & 10) 0.684 Tent peg hammer x1 1.050 Sand flag x1 0.300 Window sun nets for mosquitoes x4
3.100 Helinox chairs x2 1.210 Stools x2 0.054 Blue & grey seat mats x2 1.054 Table top x1 1.178 Table legs x1 1.010 Metho stove & lighters etc 1.850 Metho 1 litre x2 0.700 Bucket with lid x1
0.806 Sleeping mat blue Thermarest x1 1.110 Sleeping mat brown Thermarest x1 0.400 Sleeping mat 3/4 Thermarest x1 0.278 Sleeping mat grey foam x1 0.286 Sleeping mat blue foam x1 3.000 Sleeping bags x2
0.500 First aid x1 0.256 Tick freeze spray x1 0.300 Braun tooth brush 2xAA x2 2.000 Personal items 1.500 Toilet paper 10 rolls + 3 emergency
0.256 Camera Canon G9X + 2 add batteries x1 0.700 Paper maps Hema / Gregorys x10 3.000 Atlas x2 0.370 GPS + cable + bracket x1 0.200 Mobile x1 0.800 portable radio
0.256 Torch large USB 26650 x1 0.102 Torch medium USB 18650 x1 0.150 Torch head USB 16340 x2 0.032 Torch AAA x2 0.244 AA AAA battery charger 0.384 Clamp meter x1 1.086 Tool box tyre repair x1 0.366 Multi grips x1 0.192 Long nose pliers 0.268 Ratchet 3/8 inch x1 0.320 Wheel leveller x1 1.830 Jack plate x1 0.650 Tie down ratchet heavey duty x1 0.372 Tie down straps 2 metres x2 0.324 Tie down straps 1 metres x2 8.000 Tow ropes + shackles x2 1.368 3/4 inch tee handle x1 0.622 3/4 inch 21mm socket + extension x1 0.260 Builders glovers 2 sets x2 1.000 Boot carpet x1 3.000 Front rubber mats x2 0.238 Fuses box of 150 x150
0.300 12 volt dual outlet + extension x1 1.036 Spanners 6mm to 19mm (set) 0.578 Sockets 13mm - 21mm + extension (set) 0.434 Sockets small (set) 0.216 Screw driver set (set) 0.366 Air filter 0.300 Oil filter
15.000 Clothes for 2 people _3.000 Shoes & sandals 2 people 15.000 Food - cans, dry & cold 15.000 Beer (reduce weight of first item!) (not enough beer!)
548kg
-11.300 Rear seat bases & 3 head rests removed (we turn the car into 2 seats while away)
I know there are still a few thing missing and I am sure people could easily add many items to this list!
An old Boeing 747 is about 1% heavier with all the dirt in the nooks and crannies. So maybe factor in another 1% due to the environment we travel in. So lets say 30kg off you payload!
yobarr said
06:46 PM May 4, 2021
Hayden wrote:
Thanks yobarr Yes the weight scenario has certainly been an eye opener for us and a bit of a struggle to get our heads around . So just to clarify, you think that a rare weight van of around 1300kg would be pushing it in regards to the capability of a Kluger ?? FYI we have two kids under 5 , so theres a bit of stuff to pack , plus I imagine well have the usual Weber q , bikes , Portable fridge/freezer and camping chairs etc . Again , appreciate your help
Hi Hayden Unfortunately,the tare weight on the compliance plate of a caravan means diddly squat,as it shows only what the van weighed as it left the factory. ALL stuff added later gas bottles etc is part of the GVM of the van.Long story short,the Kluger will NEVER do what you want to do, given your family,and particularly when you intend to carry stuff like Weber,Bikes (NEVER on back bumper) Beer fridge,freezer,camping chairs etc. Of the two options you've presented,the Pajero is the better one,and the only one that will do the job.However,might I suggest you explore other offerings? However,the Pajero,because of its better towing capacity,may suit,but PLEASE post details on the van's compliance plate before purchase. Most important is ACTUAL weight of the van,as it stands at seller's place,followed closely by ATM (total allowed weight of van) and GTM (allowed weight on axle group). The axle capacity of the van also is important,as this could be lower than the GTM,allowing for ATM increases.Complicated? You better believe it,but always I am happy to help! Good luck with youtpr research Hayden.Cheers
Bicyclecamper said
06:51 PM May 4, 2021
I have a car that will tow 1850 kg. My previous 4wd towed 3000kg, so, I was quite happy to tow my current van of 1670kg. but this new car will not be used to tow this van, even though it can on the books. The van to me is just too heavy for it, plus the ball weight of the car is only 150kg, and my van is loaded 160, so it is too heavy. I knew this before I bought this car, and knew I would have to sell my van. Just be careful, with what car you get. A friend of mine has a Kluger 2012 AWD, and they only tow a 1300kg camper with it, even though it can carry more , they wont do it. You could look at a van like those Jayco slide out bed ends, sure they have canvas for the top middle section, but you could then use a Kluger to tow with, and that way you get the better car and petrol as well. I got fed up with limp modes on diesels, and will never get another.
-- Edited by Bicyclecamper on Tuesday 4th of May 2021 07:00:33 PM
Mariner30 said
08:11 PM May 4, 2021
My wife has a older Kluger, without a towbar,
Which is why l bought it.
I would not want to tow something that weighed that much with that vehicle.
Greg 1 said
08:15 PM May 4, 2021
I would definitely go with a Pajero for what you are wanting to do. A very good vehicle and good for a ATM van weight of 2500kgs with a 250kg ball load.
I would certainly consider the diesel due to the fuel consumption. The V6 petrol is a very good engine but not particularly economical. I should know, I had one.
Really liked my Paj but unfortunately when we upgraded our van the Paj wouldn't tow it and be legal so had to part with it and bought a Ranger. Would not have parted with it otherwise.
Eaglemax said
08:56 PM May 4, 2021
Hi Hayden
I'm wondering if you've considered the Ford Territory AWD 7 seater turbo diesel?
With the right tow pack it can tow up to 2700kg and is fairly economical. Your wife will enjoy the car like my neighbour does a lady in her 60's that shuttles her grandkids everywhere.
Thank you everyone for all of your input . Its certainly very much appreciated and I think at this stage being newbies we might stick to a larger tow capacity vehicle to be on the safe side.
So I guess the question is now Petrol V6 Prado , Pajero or V8 Landcruiser?? As mentioned before , the unfortunate thing is for the money (less than $30k ) theres not a lot about and itll be possibly a 10-15 year old car with high kms . Hence my question about a Kluger.
But again , thank you for your inputs and feedback.
Tony , thank you for the suggestion but the wife is pretty strong on the no diesel front .
Cheers
Hayden
Warren-Pat_01 said
11:14 PM May 4, 2021
Hi Hayden,
Sorry to jump in at the end - in 1984 I had standards set for a second hand 4wd.
Toyota LC was knocked on the head for leg room for me so that narrowed the field somewhat. I was waiting for the release of the Toyota 4Runner but it was delayed.
So here were my wants - no diesel, no 24v system, no metallic paint. Guess what. I bought a s/hand 1981 model Nissan Patrol wagon with 81,000kms on the clock & it HAD a diesel engine, was 24v & was metallic silver in colour!! We had that car for 16 years!!
Two more Patrols for the next 19years - both 4.2L diesels & the latest, our D-max- also a diesel!
With the right hitch it can tow 2300-2700kg. 4 litre straight 6 cylinder.
Tony
-- Edited by Eaglemax on Wednesday 5th of May 2021 12:38:31 AM
-- Edited by Eaglemax on Wednesday 5th of May 2021 12:40:12 AM
Greg 1 said
01:54 AM May 5, 2021
I think only the diesel Territory can tow 2700kg. The petrol is limited to 2300kg and both only with the right tow pack.
Mike Harding said
05:13 AM May 5, 2021
Hayden wrote:
Preferably my wife would prefer a Petrol car as she doesnt like diesels
My previous petrol vehicle returned 24L/100km when towing - my current diesel vehicle returns 14L/100km when towing and about 8L/100km when solo, plus it has 80% more torque than the petrol and is a far better tow vehicle. That's a lot to forego for a dislike....
Derek Barnes said
07:47 AM May 5, 2021
You can't go past the Patrol Y62 with its petrol 5.6 litre V8 engine.
yobarr said
08:52 AM May 5, 2021
Derek Barnes wrote:
You can't go past the Patrol Y62 with its petrol 5.6 litre V8 engine.
Hi Derek the Y62 is possibly the undisputed King of Petrol 4wds,but I would be most surprised if you could find one for the $30,000 that Hayden has available.And you would need a big bank account to pay the fuel bill.My neighbour has one,and he and his wife towed a small camper trailer from Brisbane to Cameron Corner,and back,running up the credit card on fuel.When he returned,he said he was considering selling his house to pay the fuel bill.Big,luxurious,VERY powerful it certainly is,but fuel efficient? I don't think so.Mike Harding's post,below yours,may give Hayden something to ponder? Realistically,he should be looking at something other than his listed preference,but if his wife is adamant that the car will be petrol powered, the Pajero may suffice.The Territory suggested by Tony may suit,but they do have their own issues,particularly with the transmission oil coolers that would fracture,resulting in the coolant mixing with the transmission fluid. Terminal,with a new transmission being required. Not cheap.Cheers
-- Edited by yobarr on Wednesday 5th of May 2021 08:59:48 AM
Hayden said
09:03 AM May 5, 2021
Again , thank you everyone for your input.
The other issue with the Petrol vs Diesel debate is that the car will be mostly used for short trips (ie 10 minute local drives) with only the occasional towing trip every few months on a weekend . Weve read various reports etc that this just isnt ideal for Diesel engines and can lead to potential damage and costly repairs??
The other question mark we have about diesels is whether or not theyll eventually become banned in Australia like theyve started to do overseas ? Is anyone else apprehensive about this possibility?? We dont want to invest in something that well lose all resale on down the track cause the govt has changed the laws about diesel cars in suburbia....
Its a long bow I know , but still a consideration for a purchaser .
Thanks again
Hayden
yobarr said
09:31 AM May 5, 2021
Hayden wrote:
Again , thank you everyone for your input. The other issue with the Petrol vs Diesel debate is that the car will be mostly used for short trips (ie 10 minute local drives) with only the occasional towing trip every few months on a weekend . Weve read various reports etc that this just isnt ideal for Diesel engines and can lead to potential damage and costly repairs?? The other question mark we have about diesels is whether or not theyll eventually become banned in Australia like theyve started to do overseas ? Is anyone else apprehensive about this possibility?? We dont want to invest in something that well lose all resale on down the track cause the govt has changed the laws about diesel cars in suburbia.... Its a long bow I know , but still a consideration for a purchaser . Thanks again Hayden
"Interesting" would be my reaction to your predictions! The chances of Diesels being banned during the lifetime of any car you bought now are zip,zero,zilch,nil,nada it won't happen.How could the Govt possibly ban diesel cars in suburbia? Would this mean that people who live "in the bush" would not be able to go to town? And as for "potential damage and costly repairs",I will not comment publicly,but that is easily sorted too. Driving the car like you hate it helps with my LC79 I change gears at 3000rpm or better.Cheers
Warren-Pat_01 said
09:32 AM May 5, 2021
Hi again Hayden,
Why is your wife so against diesels? Sluggish - perhaps but not an issue to us. While no first off the mark at the lights, we can certainly keep up & it only takes one set of lights to curtail the speedsters! Polluting, only if the injectors, fuel pump aren't serviced. Noisy? Only marginally. Heavy? Overridden by increased torque, far better fuel economy!
BAZZA44 said
09:40 AM May 5, 2021
Hayden a 100 series landcruiser has not been mentioned yet. You can get them in your price range but will have to look around for low mileage ones.
Barry
littledick said
09:56 AM May 5, 2021
Just to add off topic, the earlier Pajero tow capacity was 3.0T but the tow ball weight dropped to 180Kl when the van weighed over 2.5T.
Mine was just on the 180kl. For the record, pulled 2'6T van up Mt Tambourine a few yrs ago with the Pajero, got down to 2nd gear, bit scary if any steeper!!
Dick.
yobarr said
10:00 AM May 5, 2021
BAZZA44 wrote:
Hayden a 100 series landcruiser has not been mentioned yet. You can get them in your price range but will have to look around for low mileage ones. Barry
Now that's a great suggestion! With a GCM of 6760kg,and a towing capacity of 3500kg,that car would do it easily! And the wheelbase is only 60mm greater than that of a Kluger.And,as Barry has said,you can get a good one for under $30,000. But I still reckon you should buy a diesel! Cheers
Hayden said
10:13 AM May 5, 2021
Yes we have looked at the Landcruisers.
Not sure why shes against diesels - I have a feeling its to do with the truck like noise , but Id only be guessing .
So without opening a can of worms , if we were to go down the diesel path , is there one which is better than the other ? Again I think wed be tossing up between Toyota , Mitsubishi and Nissan to stay within budget and 7 seat requirements.
Greg 1 said
10:52 AM May 5, 2021
For what you are planning to do with it all of those makes are pretty good.
Personally I am a bit partial to the Pajero for reasons of comfort, ride and I really like their 4WD system which gives you the advantage of being able to run in AWD on the bitumen, due to them having a centre diff , or 2WD or lock the centre diff to give you high and low range 4WD.
The AWD is really good when it is raining and you want that additional sure footedness. The system is unique to Mitsubishi. Some others have permanent AWD and then lock the centre diff to give you 4WD, ie Landrover and some Landcruisers but none of those offer 2WD as well which helps with economy.
Warren-Pat_01 said
11:27 AM May 7, 2021
Hi Hayden,
I can't tell you which diesel is better than the other - they all have issues at times.
A friend (now passed on) had Toyota blood in his veins, owning an 80 series, then a 100 series over the 25 years that I knew him. His car was immaculate when he died,
As I said above, I had three Patrols - the first (MQ) had 81,000 kms on it when we bought it - had 400,000 on it when we sold it. Had head troubles twice & a clutch & toward the end, a rebuild.
The GQ had 93,000kms on it when we bought it, 430,000kms when we sold it 12 years later. The clutch failed once.
The GU (had it 7 years) bought with 271,000 kms, sold with 453,000 kms with no problems. Both the latter engines were 4.2L, the GQ naturally aspirated, the GU was a turbo/intercooler. Both of the latter I put gas injection systems on them BUT now the company (Diesel Gas Australia) has gone out of business!! The GU was still with nearly 500,000kms on it was still running well, producing excellent fuel economy. I had been told that engine could go to 1million kms before a rebuild was necessary.
Friends had a Pajero & their engine gummed up & cost big bucks to fix. Had they fitted a catch can, that would have saved them many thousands of dollars.
The Nissan drive trains (gearbox, transfer case, diffs) are well known to be bullet proof - I know they are #!*# heavy!!
NOTE - to get LONG life out of any engine they have to be REGULARLY serviced. I used to service mine every 7,500kms, the last one at 10,000kms due to the gas assistance. Whatever you buy, get proof of the SERVICING details. I keep a spreadsheet on SERVICING details, parts, trips etc - that goes with the car when I part with it.
Our GU had a sliding scale as Dick mentioned above with reducing ball weights as the GTM increased.
I had a 2009 Kluger and towed pretty good but only limited at the time to 2.0T. I also had a fold up drawer bar that took the ball load to 270Kl.
Traded it for a Ford Territory. Towed 2.7T. Didn't have the van or car for long, traded for a Pajero. 6 vans in 10 yrs, now have the Ford Wildtrak.
The Kluger was a good car overall, but watch your van weight. Not sure what the new one capacity is.
Dick.
I don't tow, but have a Landrover Freelander which has the Ford 2.0L Ecoboost petrol engine. It does 2 tonnes. But like all cars you need to which your car's payload. It is frighteningly quickly how payload vanishes.
Hi Hayden it pains me to say so,but the Pajero is a much more capable tow vehicle than is the Kluger.On paper,the Kluger has carrying capacity of 750kg before you reach GVM,or maximum allowed weight on wheels of car,of 2720kg.With your maximum allowed towball weight,which is indeed 200kg,you will instantly add around 300kg to your car's rear axle,having removed 100kg from the front axle.This means you have maximum carrying capacity of 450kg left for ALL your gear,family,tools etc. Unfortunately,I do not recall the carrying capacity of the car's rear axle,but that is something to be very wary of.When I get home,I will look in my records to see if I can find that for you.Maximum allowed total weight of car and van (GCM) is 4720kg,but you will never be able to get near that because towball weight becomes part of the car's weight when the van is attached.The best you're ever likely to achieve is around 4500kg,with absolutely perfect loading of the car.The Pajero,on the other hand,has payload of around 780kg but a much higher GCM of 5530kg,so towing a 2000kg van could be done easily,with its 5520kg GCM (maximum total weight on wheels of car and van).Pajero tow capacity is 2500kg,so you might be able to get weight out of the car,and into the van? Whilst I am absolutely NO fan of Pajeros,they have proven to be good,reliable vehicles for many thousands of families,over many years. The Kluger too is a grear car,but I think that it would struggle to do what you want.Weights are a minefield for "newbies",and are misunderstood by many of the more experienced vanners,so please feel free to ask questions.Remember,the only silly question is the one that wasn't asked! Cheers
We don't have kids!
Example of payload in our car:
Be very careful of what you add. It adds up extremely quickly and you have no capacity for critical items!
We don't have a tow bar which weigh a far bit themselves, bull bar, draw system, tool box, aerials, driving lights, winch, under body protection, roof platform (did have one, got rid of it to save weight), boat, outboard, or kayak, life vests, fishing equipment, UHF radio (looking at getting one), BBQ & cleaning equipment (boil only & buy fried food when in town). We only have a tiny fridge and small battery. Our wheels are small at 255/60 R18 30kg each.
Items added to our car:
145.000 People (one has to reduce a bit!) x2
12.000 Roof rack rails & 1 pair cross bars x1
_3.600 Second pair cross bars x1
_4.000 Solar panel & tyre bracket x1
30.000 Wheel second spare x1
_4.600 Fuel rack aluminium x1
36.000 Fuel tanks 10 litres x4
_3.000 Fuel rack aluminium small x1
_9.000 Fuel tanks 5 litres x2
_0.080 Fuel tank nozzle x2
15.200 Solar panels x1
12.000 Sand tracks x4
12.000 Awning x1
20.972 Water container 10 litre 0.486 x2
42.656 Water container 5 litre 0.332 x8
_3.414 Water container 1 litre 0.138 x3
_1.000 Thermos flask x1
_3.700 Fire extinguishers 1kg x2
_0.300 Hi vis vests x2
16.000 Compressor 4.5kg x3
_1.350 Air tank 4 litres x1
_0.636 Air dryer x1
_0.388 Pressure gauge x1
_0.084 Pressure gauge electronic x2
_0.132 Fitting x1
_0.556 Air hose 6 metre ARB orange x1
_0.426 Air hose 2 metre blue x1
_0.362 Air hose 1.5 metre blue x1
_0.264 Air hose 0.8 metre blue x1
_0.106 Air duster cleaner x1
_2.100 Jumper leads 175 anderson to clamp x1
_3.900 Jumper leads 300 amp continuous x1
29.000 Battery 26ah 8.35kg + brackets x3
_1.000 MPPT x1
_1.490 6awg 4m 50ah anderson x1
_0.954 8awg 4m 50ah anderson x1
_0.254 12awg 2.2m anderson x1
_0.342 12awg 2m 50/35 ah anderson x1
_0.282 12awg 35ah fridge lead 1
_0.112 Fridge power lead x1
_0.210 Fridge 240 volt lead x1
15.000 Fridge 28 litres inc. extra insulation x1
_0.100 12 volt lead 1m x3
_0.700 White towel to cover fridge x1
0.216 Window sun shade front x1
0.366 Window sun shade rest of windows x1
6.500 Mosquito enclosure x1
1.000 Ground sheet heavy x1
0.626 Ground sheet tent cover light x1
1.088 Tent poles telescopic 0.544 x2
1.900 Tent poles and pegs x2
1.600 Tent ropes & pegs (10 & 10)
0.684 Tent peg hammer x1
1.050 Sand flag x1
0.300 Window sun nets for mosquitoes x4
3.100 Helinox chairs x2
1.210 Stools x2
0.054 Blue & grey seat mats x2
1.054 Table top x1
1.178 Table legs x1
1.010 Metho stove & lighters etc
1.850 Metho 1 litre x2
0.700 Bucket with lid x1
0.806 Sleeping mat blue Thermarest x1
1.110 Sleeping mat brown Thermarest x1
0.400 Sleeping mat 3/4 Thermarest x1
0.278 Sleeping mat grey foam x1
0.286 Sleeping mat blue foam x1
3.000 Sleeping bags x2
0.500 First aid x1
0.256 Tick freeze spray x1
0.300 Braun tooth brush 2xAA x2
2.000 Personal items
1.500 Toilet paper 10 rolls + 3 emergency
0.256 Camera Canon G9X + 2 add batteries x1
0.700 Paper maps Hema / Gregorys x10
3.000 Atlas x2
0.370 GPS + cable + bracket x1
0.200 Mobile x1
0.800 portable radio
0.256 Torch large USB 26650 x1
0.102 Torch medium USB 18650 x1
0.150 Torch head USB 16340 x2
0.032 Torch AAA x2
0.244 AA AAA battery charger
0.384 Clamp meter x1
1.086 Tool box tyre repair x1
0.366 Multi grips x1
0.192 Long nose pliers
0.268 Ratchet 3/8 inch x1
0.320 Wheel leveller x1
1.830 Jack plate x1
0.650 Tie down ratchet heavey duty x1
0.372 Tie down straps 2 metres x2
0.324 Tie down straps 1 metres x2
8.000 Tow ropes + shackles x2
1.368 3/4 inch tee handle x1
0.622 3/4 inch 21mm socket + extension x1
0.260 Builders glovers 2 sets x2
1.000 Boot carpet x1
3.000 Front rubber mats x2
0.238 Fuses box of 150 x150
0.300 12 volt dual outlet + extension x1
1.036 Spanners 6mm to 19mm (set)
0.578 Sockets 13mm - 21mm + extension (set)
0.434 Sockets small (set)
0.216 Screw driver set (set)
0.366 Air filter
0.300 Oil filter
15.000 Clothes for 2 people
_3.000 Shoes & sandals 2 people
15.000 Food - cans, dry & cold
15.000 Beer (reduce weight of first item!) (not enough beer!)
548kg
-11.300 Rear seat bases & 3 head rests removed (we turn the car into 2 seats while away)
I know there are still a few thing missing and I am sure people could easily add many items to this list!
An old Boeing 747 is about 1% heavier with all the dirt in the nooks and crannies. So maybe factor in another 1% due to the environment we travel in. So lets say 30kg off you payload!
Hi Hayden Unfortunately,the tare weight on the compliance plate of a caravan means diddly squat,as it shows only what the van weighed as it left the factory. ALL stuff added later gas bottles etc is part of the GVM of the van.Long story short,the Kluger will NEVER do what you want to do, given your family,and particularly when you intend to carry stuff like Weber,Bikes (NEVER on back bumper) Beer fridge,freezer,camping chairs etc. Of the two options you've presented,the Pajero is the better one,and the only one that will do the job.However,might I suggest you explore other offerings? However,the Pajero,because of its better towing capacity,may suit,but PLEASE post details on the van's compliance plate before purchase. Most important is ACTUAL weight of the van,as it stands at seller's place,followed closely by ATM (total allowed weight of van) and GTM (allowed weight on axle group). The axle capacity of the van also is important,as this could be lower than the GTM,allowing for ATM increases.Complicated? You better believe it,but always I am happy to help! Good luck with youtpr research Hayden.Cheers
I have a car that will tow 1850 kg. My previous 4wd towed 3000kg, so, I was quite happy to tow my current van of 1670kg. but this new car will not be used to tow this van, even though it can on the books. The van to me is just too heavy for it, plus the ball weight of the car is only 150kg, and my van is loaded 160, so it is too heavy. I knew this before I bought this car, and knew I would have to sell my van. Just be careful, with what car you get. A friend of mine has a Kluger 2012 AWD, and they only tow a 1300kg camper with it, even though it can carry more , they wont do it. You could look at a van like those Jayco slide out bed ends, sure they have canvas for the top middle section, but you could then use a Kluger to tow with, and that way you get the better car and petrol as well. I got fed up with limp modes on diesels, and will never get another.
-- Edited by Bicyclecamper on Tuesday 4th of May 2021 07:00:33 PM
Which is why l bought it.
I would not want to tow something that weighed that much with that vehicle.
I'm wondering if you've considered the Ford Territory AWD 7 seater turbo diesel?
With the right tow pack it can tow up to 2700kg and is fairly economical. Your wife will enjoy the car like my neighbour does a lady in her 60's that shuttles her grandkids everywhere.
Check it out.
www.carsguide.com.au/car-advice/ford-territory-diesel-engine-problems-towing-and-price-74652
Tony
Sorry to jump in at the end - in 1984 I had standards set for a second hand 4wd.
Toyota LC was knocked on the head for leg room for me so that narrowed the field somewhat. I was waiting for the release of the Toyota 4Runner but it was delayed.
So here were my wants - no diesel, no 24v system, no metallic paint. Guess what. I bought a s/hand 1981 model Nissan Patrol wagon with 81,000kms on the clock & it HAD a diesel engine, was 24v & was metallic silver in colour!! We had that car for 16 years!!
Two more Patrols for the next 19years - both 4.2L diesels & the latest, our D-max- also a diesel!
That's ok Hayden
Territory's also come in petrol
https://www.carsales.com.au/cars/details/2009-ford-territory-ts-sy-mkii-auto-awd/OAG-AD-19756368?pageSource=details&id=OAG-AD-19756368
With the right hitch it can tow 2300-2700kg. 4 litre straight 6 cylinder.
Tony
-- Edited by Eaglemax on Wednesday 5th of May 2021 12:38:31 AM
-- Edited by Eaglemax on Wednesday 5th of May 2021 12:40:12 AM
My previous petrol vehicle returned 24L/100km when towing - my current diesel vehicle returns 14L/100km when towing and about 8L/100km when solo, plus it has 80% more torque than the petrol and is a far better tow vehicle. That's a lot to forego for a dislike....
You can't go past the Patrol Y62 with its petrol 5.6 litre V8 engine.
Hi Derek the Y62 is possibly the undisputed King of Petrol 4wds,but I would be most surprised if you could find one for the $30,000 that Hayden has available.And you would need a big bank account to pay the fuel bill.My neighbour has one,and he and his wife towed a small camper trailer from Brisbane to Cameron Corner,and back,running up the credit card on fuel.When he returned,he said he was considering selling his house to pay the fuel bill.Big,luxurious,VERY powerful it certainly is,but fuel efficient? I don't think so.Mike Harding's post,below yours,may give Hayden something to ponder? Realistically,he should be looking at something other than his listed preference,but if his wife is adamant that the car will be petrol powered, the Pajero may suffice.The Territory suggested by Tony may suit,but they do have their own issues,particularly with the transmission oil coolers that would fracture,resulting in the coolant mixing with the transmission fluid. Terminal,with a new transmission being required. Not cheap.Cheers
-- Edited by yobarr on Wednesday 5th of May 2021 08:59:48 AM
"Interesting" would be my reaction to your predictions! The chances of Diesels being banned during the lifetime of any car you bought now are zip,zero,zilch,nil,nada it won't happen.How could the Govt possibly ban diesel cars in suburbia? Would this mean that people who live "in the bush" would not be able to go to town? And as for "potential damage and costly repairs",I will not comment publicly,but that is easily sorted too. Driving the car like you hate it helps with my LC79 I change gears at 3000rpm or better.Cheers
Why is your wife so against diesels? Sluggish - perhaps but not an issue to us. While no first off the mark at the lights, we can certainly keep up & it only takes one set of lights to curtail the speedsters! Polluting, only if the injectors, fuel pump aren't serviced. Noisy? Only marginally. Heavy? Overridden by increased torque, far better fuel economy!
Barry
Just to add off topic, the earlier Pajero tow capacity was 3.0T but the tow ball weight dropped to 180Kl when the van weighed over 2.5T.
Mine was just on the 180kl. For the record, pulled 2'6T van up Mt Tambourine a few yrs ago with the Pajero, got down to 2nd gear, bit scary if any steeper!!
Dick.
Now that's a great suggestion! With a GCM of 6760kg,and a towing capacity of 3500kg,that car would do it easily! And the wheelbase is only 60mm greater than that of a Kluger.And,as Barry has said,you can get a good one for under $30,000. But I still reckon you should buy a diesel! Cheers
I can't tell you which diesel is better than the other - they all have issues at times.
A friend (now passed on) had Toyota blood in his veins, owning an 80 series, then a 100 series over the 25 years that I knew him. His car was immaculate when he died,
As I said above, I had three Patrols - the first (MQ) had 81,000 kms on it when we bought it - had 400,000 on it when we sold it. Had head troubles twice & a clutch & toward the end, a rebuild.
The GQ had 93,000kms on it when we bought it, 430,000kms when we sold it 12 years later. The clutch failed once.
The GU (had it 7 years) bought with 271,000 kms, sold with 453,000 kms with no problems. Both the latter engines were 4.2L, the GQ naturally aspirated, the GU was a turbo/intercooler. Both of the latter I put gas injection systems on them BUT now the company (Diesel Gas Australia) has gone out of business!! The GU was still with nearly 500,000kms on it was still running well, producing excellent fuel economy. I had been told that engine could go to 1million kms before a rebuild was necessary.
Friends had a Pajero & their engine gummed up & cost big bucks to fix. Had they fitted a catch can, that would have saved them many thousands of dollars.
The Nissan drive trains (gearbox, transfer case, diffs) are well known to be bullet proof - I know they are #!*# heavy!!
NOTE - to get LONG life out of any engine they have to be REGULARLY serviced. I used to service mine every 7,500kms, the last one at 10,000kms due to the gas assistance. Whatever you buy, get proof of the SERVICING details. I keep a spreadsheet on SERVICING details, parts, trips etc - that goes with the car when I part with it.
Our GU had a sliding scale as Dick mentioned above with reducing ball weights as the GTM increased.