SmartBar Avida Caravans and Motorhomes Agnes Blues Roots and Rock Festival
Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Warranty and insurance issues if you replace your towball


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 11
Date:
Warranty and insurance issues if you replace your towball


Hey guys,

In order to get a refund from a caravan retailer, under Australian Consumer Law (ACL), for a defective new camper, I undertook a two-and-a-half-year lawsuit in a Victorian Court against them. It has been settled prior to the trial that was listed for hearing in Spring, 2026.

I thought you might like to hear about some of the car and caravan warranty and insurance implications that arose in the matter, which may affect anyone who uses a tow coupling that replaces their cars towball such as a DO 35, Hitch-Ezy, McHitch, for example.

Firstly, if you look at the Australian Standard 4177 series, you will find an AS for 50mm towballs, one for coupling body for ball couplings, and an AS for towbars and towing brackets. There are no Australian Standards for any coupling that replaces your towball.

Car manufacturers test their vehicles fitted with a 50mm towball and loads applied to the towball (its called Type Testing). Ill attach a PDF of my cars, if I can. If you replace the towball, whatever you replace it with is unlikely to have been tested by the car manufacturer with your car.

Please read your car manufacturers warranty booklet, and your insurers Product Disclosure Statement (PDS), to see what is not covered unless fitted as original equipment by the car manufacturer. My car warranty book states Examples of the type of alterations not covered are installing accessories such as trailer hitches. My car insurance PDS states We will not pay for any loss, damage or legal liability caused directly or indirectly by the use or application of car parts or accessories which are not recommended or specified by the manufacturer. That will include anything replacing the towball. Look at the same documents for your caravan or trailer, for the same reason, although it is likely the car is your main focus.

Take note from these documents what you will be exposed to if you replace your towball with something else such as a pin or similar that towball-replacing couplings use. You may not succeed with a claim if the replacement component for the towball (the pin), and probably the main coupling as well, is the cause of any damage. My car manufacturer confirmed this in writing with my car, and this was evidence for the Court. Replacing original equipment may give the insurer the right to reject your claim (its called an exclusion clause). Given my own professional management background in the insurance industry running a national liability function the teams who accept or reject your claims if the problem is correctly identified, I would expect your car insurance claim would be rejected. Insurers are not your friends and they only need an excuse.

You will have a lot of money tied up in your car and caravan, so you need to be sure your car and caravan is covered by your warranties and insurance. Please check it yourself and contact your insurer if you are unsure - and get it in writing.

Let us know what your warranty and insurance PDS says.



Attachments
__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 647
Date:

You may not succeed with a claim if the replacement component for the towball (the pin), and probably the main coupling as well, is the cause of any damage.

So how did the coupling CAUSE the damage?

Cheers,

Peter



__________________

OKA196 DIY, self contained 4WD motorhome, 1280W PV, 326Ah of CALB LiFePO4 batteries, 1.3kW inv, 310L water, 350-450L diesel.



Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 11
Date:

Hi Peter,

I didn't say the coupling caused any damage. However, there is a coupling on the market that increases the load on your towbar (which they should not do), and I am aware from some coupling manufacturers that couplings have been known to disconnect for whatever reasons. An insurer will likely reject a claim simply because you used a non-original equipment manufacturer (OEM) component, which is against their policy and/or you failed to tell them. Whether you can argue against that with engineering evidence or not, you would have to first prove the replacement coupling made no difference, then have to have the insurers decision reviewed, ultimately by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA). My point is that replacing a towball with something else leads to a world of pain if something goes wrong - and caring about it then is too late. 

Cheers

Clive



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 647
Date:

This is all mindless speculation that applies to almost everything in everyday life.
You have actually told us nothing at all about what your real issue was. Unless you do that, this is a waste of space.
Cheers,
Peter

__________________

OKA196 DIY, self contained 4WD motorhome, 1280W PV, 326Ah of CALB LiFePO4 batteries, 1.3kW inv, 310L water, 350-450L diesel.



Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 11
Date:

The article is simply preventative advice to people to check their warranty and insurance if they replace their towballs, so they know what is at stake. 

 



__________________


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 98
Date:

Peter_n_Margaret wrote:

This is all mindless speculation that applies to almost everything in everyday life.


 And this from a man who regularly lectures us that everything must conform to Australian Standards or our insurance will be invalid and it'll probably cause a plague of locusts too.

 



__________________


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 11
Date:

Hi BBN2
Are you referring to the previous commenter?
Cheers


__________________


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 98
Date:

Yes, that's why I quoted him.

For some years he's been inclined to bob up regularly and lecture posters about how they should abide by Aus. Standards and, incorrectly, suggesting they were law. Now, he decides they don't really matter.

Thank you for bringing this to our attention CliveB - now that you make it clear it is a pretty obvious and sensible position for manufacturers and insurers to take, after all the snatch load from a 3T caravan is considerable and it's to keep things safe that we have Aus. standards for towing equipment.


__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 647
Date:

Please do not misrepresent me.
Standards are particularly useful documents and those that are represented in ADRs are particularly pertinent.
However, Clive has just finished telling us that the components he is discussing are NOT covered by the Standard, but they are legislated in ADR62.
www.couplemate.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/ADR62.pdf
Cheers,
Peter

__________________

OKA196 DIY, self contained 4WD motorhome, 1280W PV, 326Ah of CALB LiFePO4 batteries, 1.3kW inv, 310L water, 350-450L diesel.



Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 11
Date:

Thank you BBN2, and see my response to Peter.



-- Edited by Clive Britten on Wednesday 11th of November 2026 02:23:04 PM



-- Edited by Clive Britten on Wednesday 11th of November 2026 02:35:37 PM

__________________


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 11
Date:

Peter_n_Margaret wrote:

Please do not misrepresent me.
Standards are particularly useful documents and those that are represented in ADRs are particularly pertinent.
However, Clive has just finished telling us that the components he is discussing are NOT covered by the Standard, but they are legislated in ADR62.
www.couplemate.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/ADR62.pdf
Cheers,
Peter


 

Well, Peter, that's not quite right either. An ADR is not legislation, but I'm not here to split hairs. If you and BBN2 want the full story, search my name on my Go Fund Me page. There's no cost or risk, but I've outlined what happened that is behind my post. Remember, I've put my money and mouth behind the action I took, whereas some people only put their mouth behind things. ADR 62/02 is rubbish and the ACCC has earmarked safety standards for review this financial year by them. I've made a submission to the ACCC for a product recall on a coupling, and it would be great if all the towing community got behind it and echoed my call. I'd also like to see future towing community people use the fundraiser page also when they have to do what I did, and I really don't care if I don't raise a cent - at least I don't get blocked in saying what needs to be said.

I'm sure there will be interest in couplings being OK to sell but not to use, and who is responsible for them, along with State/Federal conflicts which allow both to ignore the issues and wash their hands of it.

Cheers

Clive



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 647
Date:

You might not like ADR 62/02, but I suggest that it is legislated and is the law.

Standards on the other hand may or may not be legislated.

www.infrastructure.gov.au/infrastructure-transport-vehicles/vehicles/vehicle-design-regulation/australian-design-rules
www.legislation.gov.au/F2007L02226/latest/details
Cheers,
Peter



-- Edited by Peter_n_Margaret on Wednesday 11th of November 2026 03:06:17 PM

__________________

OKA196 DIY, self contained 4WD motorhome, 1280W PV, 326Ah of CALB LiFePO4 batteries, 1.3kW inv, 310L water, 350-450L diesel.



Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 11
Date:

Peter, your own references refer to the appropriate legislation, being the Road Vehicles Standards Act.

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 647
Date:

You seem to be confusing the Road Vehicle Standards Act 2018 which is administered by Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications, Sport and the Arts who develop ADRs (such as ADR 62/02, which are legislated) with Standards Australia who are an independent, non Government organisation who (for example) developed AS 4177, which are not legislated in their own right, but might be included in an ADR which is legislated.
Cheers,
Peter

 



-- Edited by Peter_n_Margaret on Wednesday 11th of November 2026 07:40:30 PM

__________________

OKA196 DIY, self contained 4WD motorhome, 1280W PV, 326Ah of CALB LiFePO4 batteries, 1.3kW inv, 310L water, 350-450L diesel.



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1444
Date:

We need Yobar back.

__________________
Wol


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 23
Date:

Hello Clive,

I have read your gofundme page, Quite a story. Were you happy with the settlement? (This is Not a question about the terms).

regards



-- Edited by Wol on Wednesday 11th of November 2026 10:51:58 PM

__________________


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 11
Date:

Hi Wol, thanks for reading my gofundme page. For legal reasons I cannot comment on the settlement at all.

What I am not happy about is Australian Consumer Law (ACL) putting consumers through a process designed to fund lawyers, allow retailers and manufacturers to hide behind their business insurers, for Courts to allow insurers to run interference with the legal system, and for ACL to be backwards - consumers should only have to provide reasonable cause for sellers to have to fund their own investigations and to prove their products are legitimate. And, of course, for the caravan and aftermarket industry to be so unregulated. All of this is why I am posting and sharing this information, starting with the insurance post above (which is just a simple start) which people can explore themselves and work out without much difficulty. There have been various people with lemon products sharing their experiences in the past, I'm just trying something different with the gofundme approach.
Cheers
Clive

__________________


Guru

Status: Online
Posts: 668
Date:

All very interesting.

Just a few points.

Firstly, there is no need for the Australian Standards to specify the standards that you are required to meet when replacing your coupling with another device. This is because the required standards are specified in Section 12 of ADR 62/02.

https://www.legislation.gov.au/F2007L02226/latest/text

It is standard practice for car manufacturers to include a clause that excludes warranty claims if aftermarket accessories cause damage to the vehicle and I would suggest it is probably contained in every warranty, and rightly so. In your case the question to be asked is whether the hitch caused the damage, the failure of the shank or was it caused by the way the vehicle was loaded and or being driven. You could state what you like but the car manufacturer nor the caravan manufacturer would have no way of knowing how you loaded the vehicle or the way it was driven.

Given that you state you were in the insurance industry associated with approving and rejecting claims it is ironic now that you are on the other side of the fence. If you read my past posts you will see that I have dealt with unreasonable insurance companies and the last one had AFCA involved. Any decision would have been made by the Ombudsman but it didnt come to that as the insurance company paid out despite three insurance assessors and many people around me saying we wouldnt win. As you well know insurance companies work on the odds that the majority of claimants will not put up a fight when a claim is refused.

Again, as you will so well know, insurance companies can write anything they like in a PDS but AFCA or a court can over rule clauses they consider unreasonable etc. I agree insurance companies are not your friend and you only have to look who own the largest buildings in every major city, along with banks and law companies.

I see you stated in your answer to Peter that you didnt say that the coupling caused any damage but on your Go Fund Me page you state there was damage to your tow vehicle which was repaired by the insurance company.

Actually, Peter is correct. The ADRs are a Legislative Instrument under Section 12 of the Road Vehicles Standards Act 2018.

A legislative instrument (often called delegated legislation, subordinate legislation, or statutory instruments) is a law made by a person or bodysuch as a minister, government department, or office holderwho has been given the power to do so by an Act of Parliament.

Legislative instruments or LIs are laws on matters of detail made by a person or body authorised to do so by the relevant authorising legislation. Examples of LIs include regulations, rules and determinations. Under the Legislation Act 2003, all legislative instruments must be registered on the Federal Register of Legislation.

So in reading here and your Go Fund Me page you took on the caravan seller for a refund for the camper and not just for the coupling. Personally I think you would of lost anyway because it would be almost certain that the camper manufacturer would put forward the suggestion of a different replacement coupling.  The Court, on the basis that the coupling is only one small but important element of the camper as a whole, would in all possibility consider it to be an acceptable solution.

Im no engineer but personally I would like to see the calculations that you had an equivalent tow ball weight of 563kg simply because of the 150mm setback. My son, who is an engineer would take great delight in explaining the calculations to me.

Looking at the X9, which I take would be a similar size to yours, the specifications state it has a tare weight of approximately 850kg, a GVM of approximately 1600kg and importantly a tow ball weight of 70kg to 75kg unloaded. Interesting that they now use a DO35 hitch.

So if we take the 75kg, multiplied by your engineers 2.26 coupling factor, we have a 169.5kg equivalent download. So in loading your camper, somehow if the figures are correct, you added 393.5kg on the loading. All approximate really because I do not know what your specifications are.

Just for the record, I had an issue with my tow bar shank socket in that the welds were cracking and a friend of mine confirmed that it was due to the poor welding. As it was a car manufacturers tow bar I made a warranty claim. They wrote back wanting a large amount of detail that would have taken considerable time and expense. Was it worth fighting? Of course not because it they had accepted my claim then in all probability I would have received a tow bar of the same poor quality. Interestingly I mentioned it to a very good friend who has the same type of vehicle and he had exactly the same issue. We both now have aftermarket tow bars.

At the end of the day I think your lawyers saw you coming and I think you made the wrong pathway choice.

Good luck
Tim

 



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1628
Date:

Once again an accurate description and  explanation of the problem. Personally, I would take any post by Tim Tim as being correct. Judging by his previous efforts, he always does his homework.

As for your suggestion Rod regarding a banished poster from here, I'm sure that he is much happier where he is, among folks who think like he does.



-- Edited by Magnarc on Friday 13th of November 2026 07:50:06 AM



-- Edited by Magnarc on Friday 13th of November 2026 07:51:10 AM

__________________

"When all is said and done, more is said than done"

Simeon Craik.



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 647
Date:

A draft of a revision of AS 4177 has been released for public comment.

The major changes in this edition are as follows:
Amalgamation of the five parts of AS 4177 into one document.
The addition of safety chain connectors.
Different performance requirements for towballs and coupling bodies where the towing vehicle is over 5.0 t GVM.
Coupling-body requirements have been expanded and clarified, including loading, ball pull-out, protective coatings, hazardous projections and installation information.
Electrical connectors updated to more strictly define contact functions.
Electrical connector voltage coverage has changed to 12 V, 24 V and 48 V systems.
Revision of electrical connector requirements using performance criteria to allow more design freedom whilst retaining backward compatibility

https://hvia.asn.au/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Caravan-and-Light-Trailer-Towing-Components-Australian-Standard-Draft.pdf

Cheers,

Peter

 



__________________

OKA196 DIY, self contained 4WD motorhome, 1280W PV, 326Ah of CALB LiFePO4 batteries, 1.3kW inv, 310L water, 350-450L diesel.



Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 11
Date:

Always interesting to read the feedback. Again, there is so much I cannot say for legal reasons. I've attached a redacted (for legal reasons) copy of the first of several engineering reports submitted as evidence for the legal case. This report was prepared well before the formal legal processes began, and backed up later with others that are more in-depth - I do not intend nor may be able to post them. What is posted today shows the calculations the engineer did and some of his findings - knock yourselves out with this as keyboard warriors. 

My post was about giving people a heads up about insurance, but, typically, some take it in other directions. Fair enough, do what you like as it is what I expected. Some focus on damage - that was not the subject of the legal process. The legal case was consumer law - read up about that if you want because that was what the legal case was about. There was more to it than just the coupling, but I cannot comment. If you are interested, I made a claim against my car insurer about the damage - but this is completely separate from my legal case and a reason for delays. The insurer rejected it, falsely claiming no accident happened - which was dumb. This is where my insurance background sits. They also failed to properly identify the coupling issue because they didn't consider it. I got the decision reversed, and therefore approved, through a challenge via AFCA - not just their Ombudsman, but a panel. There was also a second damage incident after repairs for the first one, which was immediately approved by my new insurer (I dumped the old one) without drama. This second incident (both low speed) was the inspiration for all of my investigations as I suspected the truth had not been discovered. The car distributor supplied thousand of dollars worth of parts for free for both sets of repairs and worked with my engineer, via their Technical Manager, to identify the problems and monitor repairs. They were very supportive, and it was Kevin Flynn, their MD at the time who initially contacted me by phone whilst I was trying to get repairs organised (I did not contact them) about the damage having seen my former Instagram posts. My lawyers and I met with him to discuss the issues. AFCA later ruled the insurance company had to pay for costs of repairs and reports, etc. So set the damage aside, it's not relevant to my legal case.

The Federal Department of Infrastructure (DOITRDCA) confirmed the McHitch is an after-market component compliant with Australian Design Rule (ADR) 62/02, clause 12, and that type approvals for my car brand and its towing infrastructure did not include (never tested for use with) the McHitch. They advised that States and Territories regulate the supply of after-market components and modification of vehicles. DOITRDCA advised the suppler of the coupling is not required to demonstrate combined vehicle and coupling compliance. They advised this is the responsibility of any entity installing the coupling as an in-service modification. This meant the McHitch could be sold as an after-market component. This was part of the evidence.

I engaged a Vehicle Assessment Signatory Scheme (VASS) Engineer (the person who wrote the attached report), who reported in other, later reports that after-market products, when used on vehicles, must not alter the vehicle compliance to ADR or State regulations. A towbar, towball, and towbar bracket must be approved to ADR 62 and Australian Standard AS 4177.1 for it to be fitted to a vehicle. The McHitch changes the loads because its design moves the point of articulation 125 mm rearward from the vehicles towbar design, which has the point of articulation at the towball. We provided evidence showing my vehicles towbar being tested fitted with a 50mm ball and loads applied to the ball (its called Type Testing). A similar test is required when the arrangement is altered, as with the McHitch coupling - but the changes had not been validated or been tested to comply with ADR 62/02, so the tow vehicle and trailer no longer comply with the ADR.

I provided documented evidence for the Court of an admission by the inventor (now deceased) of the McHitch coupling that it does increase the load.

My car was determined to have an equivalent towball weight of a staggering 563kg (manufacturer rated at 250kg). Physics doesnt lie, and these findings were not overridden by anybody. My car manufacturer supported my investigations and independently engaged a VASS Engineer. They pointed to the McHitch also. My VASS engineer documented his opinions for the Court and said the car and camper combination when connected with the McHitch is not roadworthy in Victoria as it increases the load on the tow vehicle. VASS engineers have the authority to determine this in Victoria. I cannot comment on the roadworthiness in other States/Territories, as different laws may apply but the engineering stays the same. And if its unroadworthy, your insurance wont be of any use.

 

My engineer stated in another report the test prescribed in the Australian Standard would not provide the McHitch coupling with the approval of a towing capacity equivalent to (my) vehicle manufacturers rating. My legal case exposed weaknesses with the current ADR and related legislative arrangements. ADR 62/02 is titled Mechanical connections between vehicles but does not test the coupling with the towbar, and the towbar is not tested under the ADR with a towball fitted. It does not test what the title says it tests - it tests two components separately but not connected. That is why the McHitch can claim it meets ADR 62/02 because it only has to pass a strength test and have a locking mechanism. The devil is in the detail. 

And, yes, I'm aware that the ACCC is allegedly reviewing safety standards this financial year, and it's why I have made a submission for a recall of the McHitch coupling designs that extend their moment arms. It would be great if people emailed the ACCC at info.centre@accc.gov.au and request they investigate and recall the McHitch couplings - quote my reference numbers: REF4633240 and REF 4791361. As a community, we need to stop certain practices and make change because the after-market sector, and the caravan industry, is insufficiently regulated.

This is the reason I am posting this stuff - not to read the BS coming back from people trying to prove they are experts, whether that is you or others. I've put my money where my mouth is and am trying to help people avoid my situation - which I have no regrets in pursuing. Others are just using their mouth.

Cheers

Clive

 



Attachments
__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 844
Date:

All this and we still don't know the facts about the name on the hitch and the Insurance Company.

Whats the impediment in filling us in?

You cant get a libel case against you if you are reporting facts!!

B

__________________


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 11
Date:

Hi Brodie,

You are not following the bouncing ball, albeit it has been dragged all over the field. A couple of days ago I attached an entire engineer's report about the coupling - it's a McHitch - please take a look at the report. Note that the concept of an extended moment arm applies to any coupling brand with a design that extends the bending point. I also mentioned on my GoFundMe page the insurance company involved was QBE Insurance, and strongly recommend anyone using them as their insurer to shop around for a better insurance quote because QBE is just wasting your money.

Cheers

Clive



__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us
Purchase Grey Nomad bumper stickers Read our daily column, the Nomad News The Grey Nomad's Guidebook