Christmas island reviews

Dreamcaster51 · Senior Member

Christmas island reviews

Yuglamron · Guru

Difficult situation this immigration thing.

I understood International Law was to return the illegals to the last port of embarcation and the country of last embargation had to do the same.

No wonder they throw away their papers.Can't send them back if they don't know where they came from.

I feel sorry for the legitimate assylum seekers who get pushed further and further down the list because of the illegals.

They are living in refugee camps in various parts of the world and doing the right thing.

I used to work in Corrections and know colleagues who went to Christmas Island to work and they left ASAP.

Conditions for both staff and detainees were and are terrible.

Now the staff are mostly under trained and not equiped to deal with the situation and the profit for the companies running them is the golden mantra.

Whatever your views on the whole system it's not good for anybody except the big companies making big money.

It's not good for the kids or the adult detainees.

Happywanderer · The Master

I think this thread might be too political for this forum so my only comment will be, Very well spoken english I thought.

golivers travels · Guru

Christmas Island is on our must see list for the great birdlife there, feathered that is. Glenda

Cruising Granny · Guru

They are only required to provide survival strategies in detention according to the UN.
Because of all the variables we can't let them in and give them free reign in the community until their identity and health conditions and elligibility to refugee status are established.

Clyde Camel · Veteran Member

Yuglamron wrote:
I feel sorry for the legitimate assylum seekers who get pushed further and further down the list because of the illegals.

There is no such thing as an "illegal" or "illegitimate" refugee. That is a contradiction in terms. International laws to which Australia is a signatuary, require us to provide safe haven to any refugee who arrives, regardless of how they arrive.

People fleeing for their lives are not privy to the subtleties of the politics of the various nations where they seek a safe place to shelter. They have never heard of "queues" or "the right way to apply".

The whole concept of queue jumping is a political lie. It is total rubbish.

I recomend learning first hand from those who have fled their own beloved country in order to save their and their family's lives and listen to some of their stories. I met a 19-year old man from Sudan who had witnessed his brother being hacked to pieces with a machetti. He helped his brother's wife and small family to escape.

They trudged for 3 months across the desert and the two youngest children died of dehydration. They didn't have enough energy to bury them and had to leave their little bodies by the side of the road. After years in a refugee camp where there was a constant danger of murder and rape, they were finally able to get to Australia.

Well educated and having worked very hard in an abotoir in NSW, they are now rebuilding their lives. One day, when it is safe, they wish to return to Sudan.

While people smugglers are sometimes (but NOT ALWAYS) part of organised crime, you can't take this out on the victims. They deserve protection regardless of how they get here. Frequently, the only information they have is what they have been told by the smugglers.

Remember, 95% of so called "unauthorised" entrants into Australia come by air. They get treated in a completely different way to those who come by boat. WHY?

I saw on this thread reference to the quarantine issue as a comment on the merits of offshore processing. It is not an issue. Since colonial times we have managed quarantine effectively on the mainland. Offshore processing has only one purpose and that is political.

The deep emotional scars that most refugees bear due to their traumatic experiences at home are only exacerbated by being incarcerated without any idea of how long they will be suffering this fate. Even criminals, which these unfortunate peole are not, know when they will be released. It is cruel and inhumane to take away someone's freedom and not allow them to know how long they will rot behind razor wire.

I feel a deep sense of shame over the way we treat others who are much less fortunate than ourselves. Just remmeber, unless you are full-blood aboriginal, you are either an immigrant or the offspring of immigrants.

-- Edited by Clyde Camel on Sunday 8th of April 2012 01:48:31 PM

-- Edited by Clyde Camel on Sunday 8th of April 2012 01:55:58 PM