Cannot have this, its either over to expect a reply, or out transmission is finished.
I too, mentally cringe when I see that.
Takes me back to CMF days ..
Always start a transmission with "This is .+. call sign" .... "This is" alerts the recipient before the message starts. More useless trivia that sticks in the greymatter.
Just like "Cease Fire" Should be "Cease Fire ING" Cease fire is end of hostilities. Cease firing means stop shooting.
Cannot have this, its either over to expect a reply, or out transmission is finished.
That is incorrect. The originator of the radio communication (only) has the option to signal/advise "out" - It is usual for a message to enquire or order at start, respondent/s answer and finish their reply with "over", the originator may just acknowledge or provide further information. The originator of the message has the option to either extend utilising "over", after their response or finish message with over and out.
-- Edited by Possum3 on Monday 6th of January 2025 02:22:40 PM
__________________
Possum; AKA:- Ali El-Aziz Mohamed Gundawiathan
Sent from my imperial66 typewriter using carrier pigeon, message sticks and smoke signals.
Cannot have this, its either over to expect a reply, or out transmission is finished.
That is incorrect. The originator of the radio communication (only) has the option to signal/advise "out" - It is usual for a message to enquire or order at start, respondent/s answer and finish their reply with "over", the originator may just acknowledge or provide further information. The originator of the message has the option to either extend utilising "over", after their response or finish message with over and out.
-- Edited by Possum3 on Monday 6th of January 2025 02:22:40 PM
Things must have changed in the 1/2 century since I left the CMF. Mind you, my experience was as a Field Artillery Signaller, not a full time signaller.
If your assertion that the originator of the exchange has the option to finish the communication is correct, then I would have thought that their response to do so would be by saying 'roger that, out' or similar, never 'over and out'
It is correct to say "Roger" denoting I have understood message/order, "Out" Denoting I am finishing this message/conversation. The "Over" is redundant but is mainly used as a courtesy/habit.
__________________
Possum; AKA:- Ali El-Aziz Mohamed Gundawiathan
Sent from my imperial66 typewriter using carrier pigeon, message sticks and smoke signals.